Amazing fret crowning file – definitely a foolproof design
This crowning file is amazing. The no-grit “safe zone” is truly a game changer, and I think you would have to try very hard to botch a crowning job using this. You can just feel when the crowning is done, and the file just starts gliding across the fret without sanding anymore. Much faster than the standard filing methods, with lots of stopping and checking. It’s amazingly simple. The only actual drawback is that if you start your learning journey with this file, you’ll never learn how to do it the old school way, so you better not lose this tool. The only other thing to note is that the 240 grit does leave the frets a bit rougher than I’d like, so they do take a bit more work/time during final polishing. But the timed saved on crowning more than makes up for it, and then some. I posted some pictures of the progress of a single crown. Absolutely 5 stars, even a this fairly high price, it’s worth every penny.
J
Javajiles
★★★★★
Poor quality and customer service
Worked ok for a few guitars, then rapidly lost the ’diamond coating’. Contacted customer service but they made it clear they don’t stand behind their product. For better vaule and performance, stick with the StewMac Z files and FretGuru Diamond SharkFin.
R
rafael villa
★★★★★
Exelente
Fácil de usar vale la pena 👌
T
tMK29
★★★★★
Great crowning file
I am happy with this file. It works better than the lesser price files that i have tried for fret crowning. It is worth the cost.
JR's Custom Shop Guitars
★★★★★
Why wait? Get one NOW! (Guitar Tech speaking)
Wonderful tool! This is a MUST HAVE for any beginning guitar tech who is afraid of the jump off from fretboard oiling, and fret polishing and into leveling and crowning. This has taken the learning curve from weeks to mere hours. Now, do not get too over-zealous in the fact that this tool will make you a instant luthier and tech, because while it has made it quick and safe, you still need to follow a guideline or two.
For the price, this is perfect. I paid $84.99 and so far it has made that back plus more. If you look at the pictures (I wish I had a video, maybe in the future I'll make one) you will see that it leaves a perfect crown in the middle of the fret after you level. It has 2 fret sizes, so it has some versatility, and it is very accurate and predictable. Watch a few videos and you cannot go wrong with this tool in your money saving endeavor. Most guitar techs and luthiers will charge upwards of $150.00 for a fret leveling, crown and file. This tool is perfect if you just picked up a budget or used guitar and want to do the neck work yourself.
The rubber surrounding this file makes it extremely durable, and actually helps my hands not get cramped up by making this file thicker than my baroque fret files, which tend to have wooden handles that begin to hurt my palm and cramp my hand after 10 minutes.
All in all, you cannot go wrong. This is half the price of a StewMac fret file, and twice as much as a Baroque...but you certainly get what you pay for with this file.
W
Wile E
★★★★★
Should have bought it sooner, but still expensive. Safe zone gets rough too easily.
Great file and easy to use for a beginner. I went through 3 other cheaper files before I finally broke down and bought this one. Those other files would make my frets flat rather than file the sides.
Tip... make life easier on yourself and put tape or something over the end you aren't using so that you don't have to keep looking to make sure you are using the correct side. (See picture)
I'm taking 1 star away for the following reasons:
1. Though this is the best crowning file for a beginner IMO, it is way too expensive. I would have bought way sooner if it was cheaper.
2. By the fourth fret, the “safe zone” channel down the center started to feel rough. That made it harder to feel when I’d reached the safe zone, and the file didn’t glide as easily over the top of an already-finished fret.
I wasn't applying too much pressure and I cleaned each fret and brushed off the file twice per fret to prevent dust from scratching either the frets or the tool, but the channel still got progressively more rough rather than staying smooth.
Functionally, it still worked—the frets crowned correctly without noticeably lowering the top—but the center line became less defined on each successive fret due to roughness. It also made it harder to tell when the crown was finished. Polishing will address it, but I wish it would have remained smooth. I tried capture the roughness in the picture, but it is kind of hard to see.
SL 94383
★★★★★
Fantastic quality to performance ratio.!
Fast safe shipment.
Expensive.
Diamonds are a machinest best friend.!!
Diamonds cut efficiently, effortlessly.!!
Fantastic quality to performance ratio.!
Very comfortable thick silicone jacket.
Clever flip flop size design.
Fool proof design. Simply glide across worn/ grooved frets. Automatically restores the fret profile ratio.
A must have fret or any radius contour tool.
Keeps your guitar in perfect playing condition.!!!
MOGVET 93
★★★★★
Paid for itself
This worked Exactly as I hoped it would. Start up slow with not a lot of pressure and make sure you have some good buffing erasers and you will find that this is actually very enjoyable.
S
S. Scott
★★★★★
A Near Perfect Tool. If Only It Were 300 Grit...
This would be my favorite fret crowning file if it were 300 grit. I understand the trade-off here. A 240 grit file makes crowning faster, but it leaves considerable file marks on the shoulders of the fret, which require more work in the finishing/polishing stage to remove. My personal preference is to put the work into the filing stage wherein I am holding a comfortable tool.
Some reviewers have complained about the width of the top of the crown after filing with the S File. The attached photo shows that width (center) compared with what Fender ships with their American Professional II series guitars (left and right). As you can see, the S File produces a considerably narrower crown than Fender's process does. (The guitar in question needed and received a full fret leveling job after the photo was taken.)
Armando Bravo
★★★★★
Great choice!
Comfy! Works really good! Good buy especially for a starter.
John Toner
★★★★★
Music Nomad S-File vs StewMac Z-File
Diamond Coated, Safe Zone Guitar Fret Crowning File (S-File)
For context, I am a luthier of 40 years with two shops in Los Angeles County and Orange County, California.
l use diamond crowning files rather than toothed crowning files for five reasons :
1. They don't leave chatter marks behind like toothed files sometimes do.
2. They cut quickly.
3. They also work quicker on stainless steel frets than toothed files do.
4. They are more durable. They last longer than toothed files because of the diamond particles imbedded in them
5. Toothed files only cut in the "push" direction. Diamond files cut in both "push" and "pull" directions, making the job even faster.
I picked up Music Nomad's new S-File. I like to try out new tools to see how they perform and determine if I find something better than what I currently have.
I bought an S-File to compare to my Z-Files. I've been using the StewMac Z-Files for years now, and I'm a huge fan of their quality and performance.
The S-File has a nice weight and balance. It feels really good in my hand. The silicone grips are especially nice and add a comfort aspect to the design. The design with the silicone grip reduces hand fatigue and cramping, associated with other crowning files.
The file is 240 grit diamond coating with a narrow uncoated strip in the center. This prevents you from removing too much fret material and creating a low spot. This makes the file (dare I say?) foolproof. (The Original Z-File is 300 grit and costs $104.49. The Compact Z-Files come in 150 and 300 grits. They cost $98.99 each.)
Another nice feature is that you can use the curved ends of the file to dress the fret ends with a single swipe. It removes the sharp edge of the fret end and puts in its place a nice rounded crescent edge.
I did find that the design of this file made crowning the frets much faster and easier.
With the Original Z-Files, you have to file on one side of the fret, then flip the file and do the other side of the fret. You also have to be very careful when filing because the corners of the Z-Files are very sharp. If you accidentally slip off the fret, you can scratch or gouge the fretboard, even through the masking tape. I modified my own Z-Files by rounding off the corners on a bench grinder and beveling the edges with a file. You don't have to worry about this with the S-File.
At $79.99 vs. StewMac's Original Z-File at $104.49, it's hard to argue with the S-File's bang for the buck. However, StewMac does have a Lifetime Promise on their tools that gives them added value and longevity : "Our promise to you is simple and uncomplicated. If any of our products ever break, wear out, or fail to exceed your every expectation, simply return it for a replacement." Something to take into consideration when investing in your tools that make you money.
The S-File makes crowning fast and easy with a low learning curve. Pros will appreciate the ergonomics and its time-saving design. Those just starting out will love how easy this tool makes it to achieve professional results. Both will benefit from the quality and value.
I will say that the StewMac Z-File does produce a narrower contact surface which I much prefer. Although it's more work, it does give better results. The S-File's contact surface is considerably wider, compared to the Z-File. Compare the two results in the attached photos.
Having had the S-File for a while now, I find that I've gone back to the Z-Files because I get a better quality job. If I have a lot of jobs to do, I use the S-File to do a quick job and move more repairs out. I still get a good result that clients are happy with.
The price, quality, and results achieved with this well designed tool make it an affordable, and attractive option to the Z-Files for both pros and hobbyists.